Generative AI challenges IT leadership?

1. Introduction

In this article, I delve into the transformative potential of Generative AI and its impact on IT leadership within a rapidly evolving technological landscape. Drawing inspiration from the insights presented in "Modern leadership in a tech world on steroids" (1), I try to navigate through historical contexts of Generative AI and address key questions posed in the mentioned article:

  • How to deal with a technology that is still immature, i.e. how to achieve a balance in a rapidly evolving tech world?
  • What are the challenges and opportunities of implementing AI?
  • To what degree does Generative AI represent a game-changing technology?

2. What is AI?

Artificial Intelligence, as defined by Encyclopedia Britannica, encompasses "the ability of a digital computer […] to perform tasks commonly associated with intelligent beings" (2). IBM offers a complementary perspective, characterizing AI as "technology that enables computers […] to learn, read, write, create, and analyze" (3).
Reflecting on these definitions, we can distill AI as the technology empowering computers to learn from data, subsequently making predictions and decisions based on programmed patterns or algorithms. Within the realm of IT, these processes are recognized as AI training and inference. It’s noteworthy that such technology isn’t novel; it finds its roots as far back as the 1980s in forms like machine learning and pattern recognition. Examples abound, including supervised machine learning for classification, optical character recognition (OCR), voice or speech recognition, and text-to-speech/speech-to-text conversion.

3. What is Generative AI?

Having established a foundational understanding of AI and its historical evolution, we can now explore Generative AI, as an advancement in machine learning technology.
According to MIT, Generative AI represents "a machine-learning model that is trained to create new data, rather than making a prediction about a specific dataset" (4). Building upon the capabilities of traditional AI, Generative AI introduces a qualitative leap, transcending the confines of conditional probability found in discriminative models.
IBM’s definition further clarifies Generative AI as "deep-learning models that can generate high-quality text, images, and other content based on the data they were trained on" (5).
From a technical standpoint, Generative AI harnesses generative models, as opposed to discriminative ones, to produce outputs. This entails employing deep neural networks comprising billions of parameters, enabling the generation of original content or the creation of novel outputs. Notably, Generative AI models also exhibit flexibility in input acceptance, often processing prompts in a natural and adaptable manner.
Historically, although the first deep learning projects started in the 2000s, it was not before 2014 that Generative AI gained a foothold with the introduction of advanced neural network architectures.

3. A retrospective of evolving digital technologies

Over the past half-century, the proliferation of personal computers into homes and workplaces has catalyzed technological innovations, closely following Moore’s law. Key aspects include the exponential growth of memory and computing resources, the evolution of network communications and internet technology, and the ongoing trend of miniaturization.
The evolution of computing and memory resources lead to the creation of supercomputers and data centers with unprecedented capacities, laying the groundwork for cloud computing on a global scale. These developments have facilitated large-scale data processing, physical simulations, and the training of large AI models, currently setting the stage for the emergence of artificial superintelligence (ASI).
The exponential expansion of digital communication has been marked by the proliferation of internet hosts and the staggering growth of data, estimated 64 zettabytes in year 2020. The World Wide Web has democratized access to vast amounts of information, serving as a rich resource for training data sets for AI systems. Furthermore, advancements in network communication improved up to the point where video streaming is consumed more often than text message, and where voice recognition is computed in the cloud – instead of on the device – with acceptable latency, as Siri and Alexa have proven.
The trajectory of hardware miniaturization has seen a progression from personal computers to laptops to PDAs, smartphones, and wearables. Throughout this evolution, weak AI was omnipresent, powering technologies such as OCR, introduced by Ray Kurzweil already in late 70s, shorthand handwriting recognition systems such as Graffity in PalmOS, and software assistants including speech recognition technologies, first introduced on the portable device Apricot Portable in 1984.
In summary, this section argues that AI is not merely a recent invention but has been intertwined with the evolution of personal computing, evolving alongside technological advancements, and finding practical expression in various devices over the past decades.

4. IT leadership challenges in keeping up with evolving digital technologies

In retrospection, the landscape of information technologies has been characterized by constant evolution, often accompanied by steep learning curves. Within larger enterprises, embracing and implementing these advancements has historically posed significant challenges. Internal policies and external regulations necessitated rigorous scrutiny, risk assessment, and alignment with established procedures. Consequently, qualified, or validated processes often endured for decades, awaiting compelling reasons for replacement.
Put simply, large companies tended to adhere to conventional methods while contemplating the necessity and timing of adopting new technologies. Today, it’s still not uncommon to encounter businesses that maintain hard-copy archives of their documentation – a practice with its merits, notably the resilience to ransomware attacks that printed materials withstand.
Conversely, these same companies aspired to maintain a competitive edge through innovation – a pursuit inherently tied to the rapid evolution of computing technology, as elucidated in the preceding chapter. Naturally, this is inevitably fostering tension between established, time-tested practices and the organization’s vision for its future positioning.

5. Conclusion: Key concepts to take away

Having explored the nuances of Generative AI and its implications for IT leadership, let’s revisit the initial questions posed:
How to deal with a technology that is still immature, i.e. how to achieve a balance in a rapidly evolving tech world?
New technologies inevitably emerge with varying degrees of incompleteness, reflecting the rapid evolution of the digital landscape. Despite this inherent immaturity, IT leadership has historically embraced pioneering roles in testing and integrating into enterprise environments novel technologies like the first laptops, the first PDAs, and the first smartphones. It was just a matter of time until these technologies became financially viable and administratively controllable for widespread deployments all over the enterprise.
What are the challenges and opportunities of implementing AI?
Implementing AI presents a spectrum of challenges, encompassing affordability, system control, long-term support, and ensuring data confidentiality and security. Particularly, system and data controls are paramount, particularly in safeguarding sensitive business and personal information. In other words, the challenges of implementing cloud-based AI are comparable to the challenges of trusting sensitive business and personal data to cloud storage and applications.
The opportunities, on the other hand, are broader, spanning quality improvements in administrative processes, productivity enhancements across various workflows, and even transformative impacts on R&D and strategic decision-making processes if implemented and integrated correctly.
To what degree does Generative AI represent a game-changing technology?
This article pointed out that generative AI is a part of a long-term IT evolution, but also noticed that there is a qualitative shift. Weak AI, in general, has permeated numerous specialized industries and processes: from quality control in semiconductors manufacturing or automotive industries to classification in bioinformatics and medicine, to real-time recognition in mission critical areas. Generative AI, on the other hand, introduces novel capabilities and usage scenarios, broadening its potential impact across diverse domains.
In essence, the transformative potential of Generative AI lies not only in its technological advancements but also in the strategic vision and adaptability of IT leadership in leveraging these advancements to drive innovation and growth. On the other hand, IT leadership will have to balance between its visions and decisions versus potential risk and conformity assessments, and by promoting ethical, unbiased, and transparent AI solutions.

References

(1) https://www.linkedin.com/pulse/modern-leadership-tech-world-steroids-how-implement-ai-j%25C3%25B8rgensen-2oqgf/
(2) https://www.britannica.com/technology/artificial-intelligence
(3) https://www.ibm.com/topics/artificial-intelligence
(4) https://news.mit.edu/2023/explained-generative-ai-1109
(5) https://research.ibm.com/blog/what-is-generative-AI